Doctor Selection

Dermatologist vs. Plastic Surgeon: Who to See for What

Published · Haute MD Editorial Team

A clinician in a white coat holds a lighted dermatoscope in one hand and extends the other palm, with no face visible. Illustrative stock image; not a Haute MD doctor or patient.

See a dermatologist for conditions and changes of the skin, hair and nails, including skin checks and suspicious moles. See a plastic surgeon for a surgical operation that reshapes or rebuilds part of the face or body. The two specialties have different training paths and different certifying boards. The American Board of Dermatology says dermatologists complete a one-year internship and three years of dermatology residency, while the American Board of Plastic Surgery requires general surgery training first and at least three years of plastic surgery training. They overlap in a few places: injectables, mole and skin cancer removal, and scars. For those, the useful question isn't the title, it's whether the doctor is certified in the specialty they claim, and how often they perform the exact procedure you want.

At a glance

DermatologistPlastic surgeon
FocusDiseases and conditions of the skin, hair, nails and mucous membranes, including skin cancer and skin changes with aging (ABD)Surgery to reshape or rebuild, including facelift surgery, and reconstruction after skin cancer surgery (ASPS)
Training path (per the certifying boards)Four years of college, four of medical school, a one-year internship, three years of dermatology residency, then certifying exams (ABD)Five progressive years of clinical general surgery residency or an approved alternate pathway, then at least three years of plastic surgery training in an independent program or six in an integrated program (ABPS)
Certifying boardAmerican Board of Dermatology (ABD)American Board of Plastic Surgery (ABPS)
Certification lengthParticipation in continuing certification activities and assessments (ABD)Certificates have carried a 10-year expiration since 1995 and must be renewed (ABPS)
Where they overlapBotox and fillers are part of dermatology residency training (ABD); mole removal by excision or shave (AAD)The FDA names dermatology or plastic surgery for filler providers; plastic surgeons can remove skin lesions and reconstruct (ASPS)
How to verifyName search on certificationmatters.org plus the state medical licenseName search on certificationmatters.org plus the state medical license

Who to see for what

If your concern is...Start withWhy (source)
Acne, eczema, psoriasis, rosacea, rashes, hair or nail changesA dermatologistThe ABD says dermatologists treat conditions from skin cancers and drug reactions to eczema, psoriasis and acne
A mole or spot that is new, changing, itchy or bleedingA dermatologist firstThe AAD says a mole that "grows, itches, or changes in any way" could be skin cancer and should be examined; a new mole after age 30 should be checked
Removing a diagnosed skin cancer or other lesionEither, depending on the caseThe AAD describes excision and shave removal by dermatologists; ASPS says its surgeons can surgically remove cancerous and other skin lesions
Rebuilding the area after skin cancer surgeryA plastic surgeon may be involvedASPS lists reconstruction after skin cancer surgery as a plastic surgery service
A facelift or other surgical reshaping of the face or neckA plastic surgeonASPS describes a facelift as a surgical procedure to improve visible signs of aging in the face and neck
Botox or dermal fillersEither specialty can be appropriate; ask about the specific procedureABD says dermatology residents learn Botox and fillers; the FDA recommends a licensed provider "with experience in the fields of dermatology or plastic surgery"
ScarsAsk bothThe AAD says dermatologists use expertise to reduce scarring from growth removal; ASPS says its surgeons "make every effort" to treat skin cancer without dramatically changing appearance

Where the two specialties overlap

  • Injectables. The ABD says dermatology residents learn to treat normal skin aging "including Botox, fillers, and age spots." The FDA says to seek "a licensed health care provider with experience in the fields of dermatology or plastic surgery," to pick someone "trained to perform the dermal filler injection procedure," and to treat filler as "a medical procedure, not a cosmetic treatment."
  • Moles and skin cancer. The AAD says a dermatologist will remove a mole that is bothersome, unattractive to a patient or suspicious, by surgical excision or a surgical shave, and that a specially trained doctor usually examines the tissue under a microscope. ASPS says plastic surgeons can surgically remove cancerous and other skin lesions and "play an important role in treatment and recovery." The AAD says never to remove a mole at home and notes that the FDA tells people to avoid at-home mole removal products.
  • Scars. Both societies speak to scar care, from their own side. See the table above.

Questions to ask either doctor

  1. Are you certified by the board for your specialty, and may I look you up on certificationmatters.org?
  2. How often do you perform this exact procedure?
  3. Who will examine me, and who will perform the procedure?
  4. If I need further treatment or reconstruction, who handles it?
  5. Where will the procedure take place, and who handles a complication afterward?
  6. What does the plan and consent say, in writing?

How to choose between them, step by step

  1. Name the concern in one sentence. Is it a condition, a change, a procedure or a reconstruction?
  2. If it's a changing spot, don't wait for a surgical consult. The AAD advises having a dermatologist examine a mole that looks different, itches, bleeds or changes.
  3. If it's a surgical reshaping, start with a plastic surgeon. ASPS describes a facelift as surgery.
  4. If it's an injectable, check experience with the product and the area, not only the title.
  5. Check board certification for the specialty the doctor claims, and check the state license separately. The ABD notes that board certification is voluntary and is not the same as holding a license.
  6. Book a consultation and compare answers to the questions above.

Talk to a doctor

Browse Dermatologists, Plastic Surgeons or Find a Doctor on Haute MD.

Featured doctors: Dr. Anna Chacon, a board-certified dermatologist and the founder of Miami Derm, a medical, surgical and cosmetic dermatology practice in Miami, Florida; and Dr. Daniel Careaga, a double board-certified plastic surgeon in Coral Gables, Florida, and the founder of Careaga Plastic Surgery, whose practice is dedicated to aesthetic surgery.

Every Haute MD doctor is independently reviewed and editorially featured by Haute Living.

Sources

This guide is general information, not medical advice. Talk to a qualified physician about your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Should I see a dermatologist or a plastic surgeon?

It depends on the concern. A dermatologist treats conditions of the skin, hair and nails, including skin checks and suspicious moles, while a plastic surgeon performs surgery to reshape or rebuild. For injectables or lesion removal, either may be appropriate, so ask about training and experience with that exact procedure.

Is a plastic surgeon a dermatologist?

No. They are separate specialties with different residency paths and different certifying boards: the American Board of Dermatology and the American Board of Plastic Surgery.

Can a dermatologist do cosmetic procedures?

Yes. The American Board of Dermatology says dermatology residents learn to treat normal skin aging, including Botox, fillers and age spots. The FDA recommends that filler be given by a licensed provider with experience in dermatology or plastic surgery who is trained in injection.

Who should remove a mole, a dermatologist or a plastic surgeon?

The American Academy of Dermatology advises having a dermatologist examine any mole that changes, itches or bleeds, and says never to remove one at home. The American Society of Plastic Surgeons says its surgeons can remove skin lesions and help with reconstruction afterward.

How do I check if a doctor is board-certified?

Search the doctor's name on certificationmatters.org and look for certification in the specialty they claim, such as the American Board of Dermatology or the American Board of Plastic Surgery. Check the state medical license separately, since the ABD notes that being certified is not the same as being licensed.

Get Help Now

Speak with a Haute MD Physician physician

Are you a Physician physician?

Join Haute MD Network and have your profile featured alongside these answers.

Apply for the Network

Related Guides

Guide · DERMATOLOGY

How Do You Choose a Dermatologist?

Choosing a dermatologist requires verifying board certification, experience with your specific concerns, and finding the right fit for medical or cosmetic needs.

Read Guide

Guide · PLASTIC SURGERY

How Do You Choose a Plastic Surgeon?

Choosing a plastic surgeon requires verifying board certification, reviewing before-and-after results, and ensuring the surgeon specializes in your procedure.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/PLASTIC-SURGEON

What Is the Difference Between a Plastic Surgeon and a Cosmetic Surgeon?

"Cosmetic surgeon" is not a protected title — any doctor can use it. Learn the critical difference between board-certified plastic surgeons and cosmetic surgeons.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/DERMATOLOGIST

What Is the Difference Between Medical and Cosmetic Dermatology?

Medical dermatology treats skin disease; cosmetic dermatology improves skin appearance. Learn the difference and how to find the right specialist for your needs.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/DERMATOLOGIST

Dermatologist vs. Med Spa for Botox and Filler

Botox and filler are medical procedures in any setting. How a dermatologist's office and a med spa differ, who injects, and what to verify first.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/BOARD-CERTIFICATION

What Is the Difference Between Board Certified and Board Eligible?

Board eligible means training is done but certification isn't, and the status expires. How it differs from board certified and how to verify any doctor.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/BOARD-CERTIFICATION

How Do I Verify a Doctor Is Board Certified?

Verify board certification in 60 seconds at certificationmatters.org. Learn the exact steps to confirm your doctor's credentials before any procedure.

Read Guide

Guide · DOCTOR-SELECTION/DERMATOLOGIST

What Is Board Certification in Dermatology?

Board-certified dermatologists have completed a 4-year dermatology residency and passed ABMS examinations. Learn what ABD certification means and how to verify it.

Read Guide

Guide · PLASTIC SURGERY

What Is Board Certification?

Board certification confirms a plastic surgeon has completed accredited training and passed rigorous examinations. Learn why it matters and how to verify it.

Read Guide

Guide · PLASTIC SURGERY

What Is a Facelift?

A facelift is a surgical procedure that repositions facial tissues and skin to reduce sagging and restore a more youthful appearance. Learn about facelift techniques and results.

Read Guide

Are you a doctor selection physician?

Join Haute MD Network and have your profile featured alongside these answers — published on HauteLiving.com, a verified Google News publisher since 2005.

Apply for the Network