48 Hours in Positano: Where to Stay, Eat and Be Seen

Photo Credit: artem evdokimov/Shutterstock.com

Forty-eight hours is an insult to Positano, and I mean that lovingly. This is a town engineered for three-hour lunches, sunset Negronis that quietly become dinner, and boats standing in for taxis — so doing it right in a weekend means picking your battles: Le Sirenuse or Villa Treville for the bed, Arienzo Beach Club for the long, boozy swim, La Sponda for the candlelit dinner you’ll be describing to strangers for the next decade. Friends ask me some version of this itinerary before every trip to Naples, so consider what follows, along with the annotated answer key.

There is no such thing as doing Positano casually. Certainly not in summer, when reservations vanish, the coast road turns into a parking lot, and what feels like half of Instagram has descended on the same stretch of cliffside. The trick isn’t seeing everything. It’s knowing exactly where to be, and when.

WHERE TO STAY

If you’re coming to Positano for the full fantasy, Le Sirenuse is still the grande dame — and the obvious base for a 48-hour trip, since it puts you in the middle of everything with two of the town’s essential reservations already handled downstairs.

Le Sirenuse

Le Sirenuse has been run by the Sersale family since 1951, when four Neapolitan siblings converted their eighteenth-century summer villa into a twelve-room hotel; it now has 58 rooms and one of the most photographed pools on the Amalfi Coast. The ox-blood-red facade and the view straight across Positano’s majolica-tiled dome are the kind of thing that looks staged until you’re standing on the terrace and realize it isn’t. Novelist John Steinbeck stayed the year after it opened and called it “a first-class hotel, spotless and cool,” which, frankly, undersells it. This is the hotel that made Positano famous, and it still knows it.

Book Now

Villa Treville

Villa Treville was Franco Zeffirelli’s private estate before it became a hotel in 2009, and the guest list under his ownership reads like a mid-century who’s who: Coco Chanel, Maria Callas, Elizabeth Taylor and Richard Burton all passed through, and two of its sixteen suites still carry Callas’s and Leonard Bernstein’s names. Set among terraced gardens on its own promontory just outside town, it feels a world away from the Spiaggia Grande crowds despite being minutes from them by car. This is where you stay when you want Positano’s views without Positano’s foot traffic — privacy remains very much the point.

Book Now

Il San Pietro di Positano

Built dramatically into the cliffs outside town and opened in 1970, Il San Pietro pairs a Michelin-starred restaurant, Zass, with the only private beach in Positano, reached by an elevator cut roughly 60 meters through solid rock. Gregory Peck, George Clooney and Julia Roberts have all checked in over the decades, and the property’s own terraced gardens supply much of what lands on your plate at dinner. It’s the hotel I choose when I want Positano — but not quite so much of Positano; you’ll need the shuttle into town, and you genuinely won’t mind.

You really can’t go wrong with any of the three. For a first visit, though — and especially for just 48 hours — Le Sirenuse puts you right in the heart of it.

Book Now

DAY ONE: ARRIVE BY SEA

If you can, arrive by boat. It’s simply the best entrance. From the water, the whole town resolves at once — pastel buildings stacked on top of each other, church domes, terraces spilling toward the Mediterranean — and no matter how many photos you’ve seen beforehand, seeing it in person still lands. Check in, change, and head straight back to the water.

Arienzo Beach Club

Arienzo Beach Club sits in a private cove just east of Positano, reachable by a roughly 300-step staircase or, more sensibly, by the club’s own boat shuttle from Spiaggia Grande. Lunch here is not a quick affair — get a lounger, order Champagne, swim, eat, and stay long enough that the music gets louder and your afternoon plans become negotiable. It’s glamorous and social without tipping into an Amalfi Coast impression of Ibiza, which is a harder balance to strike than it sounds.

Eventually, drag yourself away and get ready for golden hour.

Aldo’s at Le Sirenuse

Aldo’s is Le Sirenuse’s terrace bar, and it looks straight across Positano and the sea — order a Sirenuse Martini, or anything built around the local lemons, and watch the town change color as the sun goes down. This is the aperitivo hour Positano was built for, and Aldo’s does not waste it on anything less than a proper view.

La Sponda

La Sponda, Le Sirenuse’s Michelin-starred restaurant, is lit each night by hundreds of candles, with musicians moving through the dining room on guitar and mandolin while the hillside glitters across the water. Chef Gennaro Russo’s menu draws on Naples, Vesuvius and the Amalfi Coast — a lemon risotto with capers is the dish people still mention years later — but the setting does at least half the work here, and it does it without apology. Yes, everyone knows La Sponda. Go anyway. It’s romantic without being saccharine, and it’s still the restaurant that explains why everyone became obsessed with this town in the first place.

Have another drink after dinner. You have nowhere to be in the morning — well, almost nowhere.

Photo Credit: zedspider/Shutterstock.com

DAY TWO: GET ON A BOAT

Breakfast should happen at the hotel, ideally outside and overlooking the water, and by late morning you should be back on it. If you’re going to splurge on one thing during a 48-hour stay, make it a private boat — charter a gozzo or a speedboat, cruise the coast, swim in a cove you can’t reach from land, circle Li Galli, and tell the captain not to hurry. The Amalfi Coast is spectacular from the shore. It’s better from the water, and it’s one of the easier ways to dodge the summer traffic clogging the SS163 between towns.

A VERY LONG LUNCH

Da Vincenzo

Da Vincenzo has operated on Viale Pasitea since 1958, when the family’s grandfather Vincenzo opened it; his grandson, who shares his name, now runs the kitchen and keeps the menu focused on fish. It’s held a Michelin Plate in recent years without inflating its prices to match the view, which in a town this photogenic counts as a small miracle. This is where I want to eat when I’m craving the food I actually came to southern Italy for — gorgeous seafood, fresh pasta, local vegetables, nothing overworked.

Il Ritrovo

Il Ritrovo sits in the hillside village of Montepertuso, run by three generations of the same family and known for grilled meats and a Slow Food sensibility that’s rare this close to a tourist town. The complimentary shuttle from Positano is worth taking — nobody needs to earn lunch by climbing several hundred stairs first. Whichever of the two you choose, don’t rush it. This is Italy. Lunch is an event, not an errand.

SHOP POSITANO

By late afternoon, head back into town and wander. Via dei Mulini and the lanes around it are filled with the things Positano does particularly well — handmade leather sandals, ceramics, linen, and the breezy dresses that have defined Moda Positano since the 1960s. Have a pair of sandals made. Buy something white and impractical. Stop for a lemon granita. Just make sure you’re back in time to change for dinner — your final night belongs to Villa Treville.

SAVE VILLA TREVILLE FOR LAST

Bianca Bar

Bianca Bar occupies the Arabian-inspired Salone Bianca inside Villa Treville, and its cocktails are made with herbs and botanicals grown on the property — the whole scene feels wonderfully removed from central Positano’s bustle. It’s intimate, a little sexy, and the kind of place where you start quietly wondering whether you can cancel your dinner plans elsewhere. Don’t. You already have dinner reservations, and they’re at Maestro’s, thirty feet away.

Maestro’s

Maestro’s sits on Villa Azzurra’s terrace overlooking Positano and the Li Galli islands, drawing much of its produce from Treville’s own organic farm under chef Vincenzo Castaldo. Zeffirelli reportedly entertained guests on this exact terrace — you’ll understand why the moment the lanterns come on, the Mediterranean turns into a mirror for the chandeliers. Lush gardens, flickering light, a view Positano itself seems to be posing for: this is how you end a 48-hour trip that never once felt rushed.

For all the talk of discovering some hidden Positano, sometimes you just want the scene — and a few places simply own it. Aldo’s is where you want to be at aperitivo. Arienzo owns the long, boozy beach lunch. Le Sirenuse remains the grande dame. Villa Treville is where you disappear when you don’t particularly want anyone to know where you are. And Il San Pietro is where you retreat once you’ve had enough of the crowds but aren’t remotely ready to leave the coast.

The biggest mistake you can make in Positano is trying to fit it all into 48 hours. Don’t. Choose the right hotel. Book the boat. Take the three-hour lunch. Order another cocktail. Watch the sunset. Whatever you miss is an excellent excuse to come back.

Read more Haute Living coverage on the Amalfi Coast here.