Who doesn’t love pizza? With cheese, without cheese, meats, vegetarian, the options are endless. With such variety, it seems like you don’t find the right pizza the right pizza finds you. Pizza has a way of making us realize La Dolce Vita, a joy of life, have you ever seen anyone mad when they eat a fresh just-out-of-the-oven slice? We haven’t either. Haute Living compiled a list of the top 5 places in the Hamptons to munch on the timeless classic.
1 John's Restaurant
This rustic Italian eatery has served Hampton goers since 1972. John’s Restaurant’s famous thin crust pizza comes in a variety of flavors including their signature spicy chicken pizza and fresh tomato basil pies. Along with pizza’s, this throwback eatery offers pasta dishes as well as scrumptious heros. Now with a refurbished dining room, John’s is an ideal destination for those looking for great food in a cozy environment.
125 W. Montauk Hwy
Hampton Bay, NY 11946
2 Nick & Toni's
At Nick & Toni’s, they make pizza the old fashioned way. Through a large wood-burning oven, the pizza is delicious and maintains that smoky old country taste. Inspired by Tuscan farmhouses, the walls to this eatery are decked out with American art as well as a mosaic design covering the massive oven. With delectable’s such as the Margherita pizza, Nick & Toni’s is a top contender for the best place to grab a pizza in the Hamptons.
136 North Main St.
East Hampton, NY 11937
3 Pizzetteria Brunetti
Specializing in authentic Neapolitan pizza, Pizzetteria Brunetti makes pizza how your Italian grandmother would make it. Tradition, the code which this Italian restaurant stands by, makes sure all the ingredients are fresh, local and organic. This classical approach may be progressive, but is the food good? Pizzetteria Brunetti’s wood fired, thin cut, crisp pizzas are delicious.
103 Main St.
Westhampton, NY 11978
4 Uncle Joe's Restaurant and Pizzeria
Were filling you in on a local secret: Uncle Joe’s Italian Restaurant and Pizzeria is the go to spot for great pizza in the Hamptons. From gourmet pies like the White Pizza with Spinach or just your simple Cheese Pizza, Uncle Joe’s has been doing it right for over 25 years. Along with great options, the restaurant has two dining rooms; one is more laid back for those coming from the beach, while the other is more upscale and chic.
258 W. Montauk Hwy.
Hampton Bay, NY 11946
5 World Pie
This late night spot-open till midnight- has an eclectic variety of pies. Feeling traditional? Try the Smoked Mozzarella with Tomato and Basil, Asian you say? How about the Mr. Tang decked out with Asian Duck, Scallion, Cilantro, Mozzarella and Goat Cheese. Feeling like the ocean breezes are tantalizing your taste buds? How about the Fresh Clam Pie with Clams, Ricotta, Parmesan Cheese and Roasted Garlic, World Pie really has a pizza for any person.
2402 Montauk Highway
Bridgehampton, NY 11932